Best Homemade Mulled Wine Recipe for Sipping and Gift Giving | Foodal (2024)

We occasionally link to goods offered by vendors to help the reader find relevant products. Some of these may be affiliate based, meaning we earn small commissions (at no additional cost to you) if items are purchased. Here is more about what we do.

‘Tis the season for all of the warm co*cktails. With the weather getting extra chilly outside, I have taken to anything that will heat me up from the inside out for co*cktail hour.

Currently, I am sitting here with extra layers on and my little space heater going full blast under my desk, getting excited to have another reason to make this mulled wine.

My husband had never tried mulled wine before last year. When he told me this, I was shocked.

How could he never have tasted the magical drink that is mulled wine? The flavor, the comfort, and the celebratory feeling you get when you drink it are all must-haves at this time of year!

Serving mulled wine was a Christmas Eve tradition for my family. Cousins, aunts, uncles, and grandparents would gather for the annual celebratory meal with warm mugs of deliciousness in hand.

It is a memory I treasure, especially since my grandfather would always sneak me a few sips…

The flavors of the warming spices, citrus, and bold red wine are natural companions, and heating this beverage brings them out even more. The scent when you make it fills your home with a tantalizing aroma, and you will never want it to go away.

Now, instead of simply making mulled wine and hogging it all to yourself (not that I would ever blame you for doing that…), you can give the gift of this fantastic drink to your friends and family for the holiday season.

This mulling mix in a jar is such a simple gift that anyone who receives it will totally swoon over. Instead of gifting premade packets that you can find at the store, our recipe includes a better variety of spices that are varied and complex, and no preservatives.

This is such an exciting gift and it offers something a little different from the usual homemade canned and baked goods. Eyes go wide once they realize what is inside the jar, and the two bottles of red that you can include to make your gift complete are always appreciated.

I recommend customizing this gift to fine-tune it a bit for each recipient. If you know they don’t like sweet drinks, be sure to choose a dry wine that will balance out the sweetness in the mulled mix.

If you know the recipient likes a little more of a sweet taste, choose sweeter and juicier bottles to tie with ribbon and add to the package.

You can even think about bringing this mix as a host or hostess gift to a gathering – if you’re lucky, they might even want to make it as soon as they open it, to share with everyone!

Be sure to read through the notes provided below the recipe for some additional tips. You can substitute fresh citrus in lieu of the candied peel if you prefer. For an added extra-special touch, our homemade candied citrus peel is nice to include as well.

Regardless of how you make the mix your own or how you package it, you can rest assured that whoever receives your kind and thoughtful gift will be beaming with happiness. It’s the perfect addition to every holiday meal that is coming up on your calendar this season.

Print

Cooking By the Numbers…

Step 1 – Chop Candied Citrus Peel and Measure Remaining Ingredients

Chop enough candied citrus peel so you have 1 cup total.

If all you have on hand is candied orange peel, it is okay to only use orange. If you don’t have any on hand, make our own at home from scratch, or use fresh citrus peels instead. The fresh citrus will be added in a later step.

Measure out the remaining ingredients for the mulling mix.

Note: If you don’t have a vanilla bean pod, you can substitute 3 teaspoons of vanilla extract. Include this as an add-on to the gift to keep the mix dry. Do not substitute vanilla powder, which is meant for baking.

Step 2 – Make the Mix

Add the sugar to a pint-size mason jar.

Layer the candied citrus peel on top.

Follow this with the cinnamon sticks, bay leaves, vanilla pod, and whole star anise.

Add a sprinkling of ground nutmeg on top.

Seal the jar.

Step 3 – Gift the Mix

To package the mix for gifting, I like to decorate my jars with a ribbon and a label to indicate what’s inside, and how to prepare it. Don’t forget to print the appropriate instructions for making the mulled wine, depending on whether you are using fresh or candied citrus peel.

Package each jar with two bottles of dry red wine, a new corkscrew or wine opener, and a small bottle of orange juice if it will be opened and refrigerated in the near future. Whole citrus and homemade vanilla extract make nice additions as well, if you choose to make your mix using one of those variations.

Step 4 – Make the Hot Beverage

Start by halving the vanilla bean pod lengthwise.

Note: If you are using fresh fruit instead of candied orange peel, peel half a lemon, half a lime, and the entire orange. Remove as much of the white pith as possible.

Add the orange juice, mulling mix, and the vanilla bean pod to a large saucepan and place it over medium heat. If using fresh peel, add it now. Add just enough red wine to cover the sugar.

Simmer the mixture until the sugar dissolves, stirring every so often.

Once the sugar is dissolved, raise the heat to medium-high and bring the mixture to a boil. Keep at a rolling boil for about 4 to 5 minutes, stirring frequently. The mixture should be thick and syrupy.

Once it has thickened, reduce the heat to low and add the remaining wine.

Heat gently for 5 minutes, but do not to bring it to a boil as you’ll burn off the alcohol. Ladle into glasses and serve.

If you like, you can strain the warmed drink through a fine mesh sieve to remove the peels and spices, and transfer it to a slow cooker to keep warm throughout the evening. I prefer to ladle carefully instead, since the citrus and spices will continue adding flavor to the mixture.